WWE Extreme Rules 2015

What a weird show in which the two rematches of the most underrated Wrestlemania encounters delivered the fewest thrills and the matches I was least looking forward to delivered far above expectations. WWE has a chronic problem with bad booking, and that problem went a long way to sinking the main event, which looked like a train wreck long before the crash actually happened. Still, two great matches on the main card (the tag titles match and Last Man Standing) coupled with an inspired pre-show match force my thumbs skyward, but keep yours near the fast-forward button on your remote.

6